CHRISTMAS OFFER Subscribe to Country Smallholding today CLICK HERE

Bill on compensation fails

PUBLISHED: 16:49 14 March 2008 | UPDATED: 08:22 28 March 2014

MARCH 14, 2008: A Bill that would have protected responsible animal owners from unfair compensation claims has failed in the Commons.

The move to amend the Animals Act 1971 did not succeed, despite the fact junior Defra minister Jonathan Shaw had told the House that it had government support.

The Private Member's Bill was introduced by Stephen Crabb to clarify the Act and limit liability for damage caused by domestic animals such as cattle and horses.

Strict liability for genuinely dangerous animals, for example large cats or venomous snakes kept as pets, would remain.

Jonathan Shaw said in the debate today (March 14): "We are pleased, as a government, to confirm our support for the Bill..."

"The case for amending the Act is, we believe, persuasive."

The failure of government to amend the Bill accordingly angered Countryside Alliance chief executive Simon Hart, who said a significant number of riding stables had been put out of business as a result of soaring insurance premiums due to the legal liability it places on them.

"This Bill addressed an inherent unfairness in the 1971 Act and would have provided important legal clarification for animal owners. While it is very disappointing that the Bill has failed at this stage, the Minister's support suggests that this is an issue that must be revisited at the earliest possible moment," Mr Hart said.

"The current situation when livestock farmers, keepers of animals and riding schools can be sued for accidents over which they have no control is blatantly unfair. This Bill will encourage responsibility on the part of keepers and boost rural businesses.

He added: "If the case for amending the Act is persuasive, then the Act obviously needs to be amended as soon as possible."


0 comments

Interact with other smallholders and post your questions

Visit our forums


More from Land

Friday, September 7, 2018

Although Britain’s record-breaking heatwave has now been broken by rain storms, the impact of the prolonged tinderbox dry summer following a longer than usual winter is likely to continue throughout this year and into next, writes Kim Stoddart

Read more
September 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018

Ask the experts: during the hot weather, here’s how to preserve dwindling water supplies

Read more
August 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018

Debbie Kingsley outlines what smallholders-in-waiting need to consider when buying their first property

Read more
August 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018

Liz Shankland continues her guide to improving herd productivity, this time investigating the importance

Read more
August 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018

The long run of sunshine and dry days of summer 2018 is impacting smallholders and their livestock and crops

Read more
August 2018
Monday, July 9, 2018

Our guide to getting your lice and mite treatment up to scratch

Read more
July 2018
Monday, July 9, 2018

Debbie Kingsley outlines the rules and regulations for smallholdings. This month: medicine records and fallen stock

Read more
July 2018
Monday, July 9, 2018

The countryside is not immune to crime - in fact, it’s increasing

Read more
July 2018
Monday, April 9, 2018

Jack Smellie looks at what to do when lambing and kidding doesn’t go to plan

Read more
April 2018
Monday, April 9, 2018

Smallholder Tim Tyne advises on the treatment of lambs which are hypothermic

Read more
April 2018

Most Read

Newsletter Sign Up

Country Smallholding monthly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

This Year’s Shows

Country Smallholding cover image

Don’t miss our comprehensive guide to rural events

Find out more

Like us on Facebook


Follow us on Twitter