CHRISTMAS OFFER Subscribe to Country Smallholding today CLICK HERE

NFU 'misquoted' in criticism of smallholders

PUBLISHED: 10:53 29 February 2008 | UPDATED: 08:22 28 March 2014

FEBRUARY 29, 2008: The NFU claims its President, Peter Kendall, was "misquoted" by The Times when he was reported as saying that smallholders should be licensed.

The Times reported that the NFU regarded the growing number of "hobby farmers" who keep livestock mainly as pets as a threat to the future of British agriculture unless they undergo tough new licensing and inspection regimes.

The newspaper quoted NFU President Peter Kendall as saying: "We have to ask, should hobby farmers be allowed to jeopardise the professional industry.

"In these days of bluetongue, foot-and-mouth disease, avian flu and increased disease threats from climate change, should these keepers not need a licence or some form of competence, to look after farm animals."

The Times reported Mr Kendall as saying that the NFU had made a formal request for new supervision of hobby farmers in a submission to the Anderson inquiry, which is examining the handling of last year's Surrey foot-and-mouth outbbreak.

There was a furious reaction from many smallholders. The Sheep Protection Society said 'hobby farmers' should not be demonised. Mary Marshall, who represents the Smallholders Forum, told The Times: "Hobby farmers often spend more on proper prevention practices than do commercial farmers, and tend to have more veterinary involvement and spend more time per animal."                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              This week the NFU issued a press release saying it was putting right "incorrect newspaper reports that claimed Union President Peter Kendall had called for smallholders to be licensed".

It said:"Mr Kendall was quoted in The Times on 18 February as saying that ‘hobby farmers' with livestock should be expected to have a licence or certificate, to reduce the risk of their activities impacting on professional livestock farmers."

"His remarks had been taken out of context and been distorted to create controversy.

"The President had, in fact, said that it may be sensible to have a debate on whether licensing, certification or other policy options could reduce the risk of diseases - such as foot and mouth - resurrecting.

"The NFU does not at present favour licensing livestock keepers, as we consider that the burden would be disproportionate to the benefit.

"If we were to consider it, it would be on the basis that any requirements would apply to all livestock keepers. However, it might be possible to make allowance in the requirements for farmers participating in recognised farm assurance schemes, so as to avoid duplication."

The NFU statement said: "We are well aware that the existing inspection regime makes no distinction between livestock farmers on the basis of the number of animals kept and we do not favour any change in that situation."

It said the NFU does not endorse the expression ‘hobby farmers' as shorthand for small-scale farmers, as there was no correlation between farm size, animal welfare and record keeping.

It said the thousands of small-scale farms in England and Wales were "an important part of rural communities and cared for livestock to the highest standards".

But it said there could be a minority of farms - big and small - that did not, and were not well enough equipped to identify disease or other risks.

This could have significant implications under the government's cost-sharing agenda, as farmers who invested in measures to reduce the risk of disease could end up paying for the consequences of farmers who did not, said the NFU.

"How to address that situation, in ways that do not add to the already huge regulatory burden on livestock farmers of all shapes and sizes, needs to be the subject of debate."

0 comments

Interact with other smallholders and post your questions

Visit our forums


More from Land

Friday, September 7, 2018

Although Britain’s record-breaking heatwave has now been broken by rain storms, the impact of the prolonged tinderbox dry summer following a longer than usual winter is likely to continue throughout this year and into next, writes Kim Stoddart

Read more
September 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018

Ask the experts: during the hot weather, here’s how to preserve dwindling water supplies

Read more
August 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018

Debbie Kingsley outlines what smallholders-in-waiting need to consider when buying their first property

Read more
August 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018

Liz Shankland continues her guide to improving herd productivity, this time investigating the importance

Read more
August 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018

The long run of sunshine and dry days of summer 2018 is impacting smallholders and their livestock and crops

Read more
August 2018
Monday, July 9, 2018

Our guide to getting your lice and mite treatment up to scratch

Read more
July 2018
Monday, July 9, 2018

Debbie Kingsley outlines the rules and regulations for smallholdings. This month: medicine records and fallen stock

Read more
July 2018
Monday, July 9, 2018

The countryside is not immune to crime - in fact, it’s increasing

Read more
July 2018
Monday, April 9, 2018

Jack Smellie looks at what to do when lambing and kidding doesn’t go to plan

Read more
April 2018
Monday, April 9, 2018

Smallholder Tim Tyne advises on the treatment of lambs which are hypothermic

Read more
April 2018

Most Read

Newsletter Sign Up

Country Smallholding monthly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Our Privacy Policy

This Year’s Shows

Country Smallholding cover image

Don’t miss our comprehensive guide to rural events

Find out more

Like us on Facebook


Follow us on Twitter