Is it advisable to help duckling from shell?

PUBLISHED: 19:30 11 May 2014

In Andy Cawthray's piece about duck incubation he appears to be helping a duckling out of its shell. When I have done this the duckling ends up with a deformed neck and remains small. So now I do not give any assistance and the duckling eventually dies in the shell. Any comments?

Andy Cawthray replies:

Thanks for getting in touch John. The image in the article is actually a photograph I took whilst working with Graham Hicks (the well known waterfowl breeder) during his last year of significant hatching prior to his retirement. Graham rarely assisted birds during hatches preferring instead for it to make its own way out of the egg where possible. He would though peel back the membrane (as he’s doing in the image) if it was blocking the hatchlings ability to breath when checking over the hundreds of eggs hatching in the incubators.

Assisting a young bird to hatch be it duckling or chick is always a risk, and as with Graham, I rarely interfere as in my experience it frequently results in the youngster not thriving.

More from Expert Advice


How can you widen your resilient reach beyond the veg garden? Kim Stoddart explains how native planting 'off piste' will help to entice those vital pollinators back onto your patch

Read more
Thursday, May 30, 2019

We pick six fruit and vegetables that reap multiple-harvests every year and can be grown at home

Read more

Most Read

Comments have been disabled on this article.

Most Read

Latest from the Country Smallholding